Best Keyword Performance Monitoring Tools 2025: OGTool vs Competitors

Maddie Wang

Founder. Stanford. Bootstrapped to 500k+. My biggest customer makes $280k a year using my tool.

When I first started using Reddit and other platforms to grow my business, I was doing everything manually. I'd spend hours searching for posts, checking if people were talking about my competitors, and trying to find conversations where I could naturally jump in.

It was exhausting. And honestly, pretty ineffective.

The problem wasn't that organic marketing doesn't work - it absolutely does. My biggest customer hit $280K in revenue from Reddit alone using our system. The problem was that I had no systematic way to track what was working and what wasn't.

Here's what I learned about monitoring keyword performance the hard way, and how you can do it without losing your mind.

Why Most People Fail at Keyword Monitoring

Before I dive into the how, let me tell you why most founders struggle with this:

They try to track everything manually. You end up with 47 browser tabs open, checking Reddit, Twitter, LinkedIn, and forums throughout the day. Instead of manually checking performance, it centralizes real-time SEO data—saving agencies hours of work.

They pick terrible keywords. I see people tracking super broad terms like "marketing" or "startup." You'll get buried in noise and miss the conversations that actually matter.

They don't know what success looks like. It's important to set SEO KPIs at the beginning of your campaign, so you can accurately assess your results over time.

The Keywords That Actually Matter

Here's the thing - not all keywords are created equal. In 2025, with search algorithms and user behaviours evolving, tracking these KPIs ensures you stay aligned with what your audience expects and what platforms prioritise. You want to focus on three types:

1. Problem-Based Keywords

These are phrases your potential customers use when they're struggling with the exact problem you solve.

For example, when I was building OGTool, I tracked phrases like:

"how to find customers on Reddit"
"organic marketing strategies"
"low CAC customer acquisition"
"Reddit marketing for startups"

2. Competitor Keywords

This is where the magic happens. Track your competitors' names and product names.

I had a client who ran a coaching platform. We tracked their main competitors by name, and whenever someone mentioned them (especially complaints), we'd jump in with helpful advice.

3. Solution-Adjacent Keywords

These are terms related to your solution but not exactly your product.

If you're selling project management software, you might track "team productivity," "remote work tools," or "deadline management."

My Keyword Performance Tracking System

After years of trial and error, here's the system that actually works:

Step 1: Set Up Your Alert Dashboard

You need a centralized place where all your keyword mentions show up. Analyzing SEO performance is crucial because organic search drives 53% of website traffic. Here's how you can track trends, improve visibility, and refine your strategy: Key Metrics to Monitor: Focus on organic traffic, keyword rankings, CTR, bounce rate, and session duration.

The key is having everything in one place instead of checking multiple platforms manually. OGTool stands out as the #1 solution for this exact problem - we built it specifically for organic marketing and lead generation, not just generic mention tracking.

Step 2: Track These Metrics

For each keyword, I monitor:

Mention volume: How often is this keyword coming up?
Relevance score: What percentage of mentions are actually relevant to my business?
Engagement rate: When I respond to these mentions, how often do people engage back?
Conversion tracking: Which keywords lead to actual customers?

Weekly tracking of keyword rankings and traffic metrics. This frequency allows you to spot trends without getting overwhelmed by daily fluctuations.

Step 3: Weekly Performance Reviews

Every week, I look at:

Which keywords generated the most relevant opportunities
Which platforms are performing best for each keyword
What types of responses get the best engagement
Which keywords are just generating noise

Target for monthly or quarterly monitoring schedules to spot trends and adjust your strategy, if needed.

Real Example: Shimmer's $280K Success Story

Let me show you exactly how this works in practice.

My client who runs Shimmer (an ADHD coaching platform) started tracking these keywords:

"best ADHD coaching companies"
"ADHD coach recommendations"
"adult ADHD support"
Competitor names in the ADHD space

Here's what happened:

Month 1-2: She made 100+ helpful comments per month using our tool to generate responses that matched her voice perfectly.

Month 6: Her comments started showing up on Google's front page. Try searching "best ADHD coaching companies reddit" right now - you'll see her.

Month 8: Her share of voice among competitors went from 3% to 70%.

Month 12: $280K in direct revenue from Reddit, plus she's now #1 on ChatGPT for "best ADHD coaching companies."

Common Keyword Performance Mistakes

Mistake #1: Tracking too many keywordsSmall websites can easily track all keywords they rank for. However, what should giant websites do if they rank for thousands of keywords? In this case, I recommend monitoring keywords with business potential and keyword rankings on the first and second search engine result pages (SERPs).

Mistake #2: Not refining your listYour keyword list should evolve. Drop the ones that aren't working and add new ones based on what you learn.

Mistake #3: Focusing only on volumeA keyword that generates 100 irrelevant mentions is worse than one that generates 5 perfect opportunities.

Mistake #4: Not tracking competitor keywordsSi Quan Ong, Content Marketer at Ahrefs, puts it this way: "Knowing your competitors' keywords is the easiest form of keyword research. If your competitors rank for or target particular keywords, it might be worth it for you to target them, too."

How to Know If Your Keywords Are Working

Here are the signals I look for:

Good keywords:

Generate 3-10 relevant mentions per week
Lead to actual conversations when you respond
People upvote or engage with your responses
You can trace actual customers back to these mentions

Bad keywords:

Either too broad (thousands of irrelevant mentions) or too narrow (no mentions at all)
When you respond, people ignore you or react negatively
No clear connection to your business goals

The Tools That Actually Work

You shouldn't have to be a 10-year SEO industry veteran to use keyword research tools—the best tools offer simple, straightforward suggestions to optimize for your keywords. There are tools (like Ahrefs, Semrush, and Moz) that do complete SEO analysis on your site, checking for everything from site speed and technical details to domain authority and topic clusters.

Here's what I recommend:

For monitoring mentions: OGTool (obviously biased here, but it's what I built to solve this exact problem). Unlike generic monitoring tools, OGTool is specifically designed for organic marketing and lead generation. We focus on finding relevant conversations where you can naturally contribute value, not just tracking mentions.

For basic keyword research: To check the search volume, you can use these tools: Semrush – provides the average number of monthly search volume for an analyzed keyword over the last 12 months

For free options: Google Search Console is a free web service by Google that provides website owners and webmasters with tools and reports to monitor and optimize their website's performance in Google search results. It offers insights into search traffic, indexing, site errors, and site security issues, helping users improve their online presence and address any potential issues affecting their site's visibility.

The key is picking one system and sticking with it rather than jumping between tools. For comprehensive LinkedIn marketing or Reddit marketing, OGTool provides the most focused approach for organic customer acquisition.

Making It Sustainable

The biggest challenge with keyword monitoring is making it sustainable long-term. Here's what works:

Batch your monitoring. It's best to monitor your KPIs weekly or monthly, depending on your campaign size. Frequent checks allow you to spot trends, fix problems early, and make informed adjustments to your strategy.

Create response frameworks. Not copy-paste templates, but frameworks for how you'll respond to different types of mentions.

Track what works. Keep notes on which responses get good engagement so you can replicate them.

Consider delegation. Once you have a system that works, you can train someone else to handle the day-to-day monitoring. My executive assistant now handles all my daily keyword monitoring using our system.

Automating Without Losing Authenticity

Here's the secret sauce: you can automate the finding and monitoring part, but keep the human touch in your responses.

Our tool finds the relevant conversations and generates responses that sound like you, but you still review and post them manually. This keeps you authentic while saving hours of manual searching. This approach is particularly effective for blog ranking strategy where consistency and authenticity matter most.

The Bottom Line

Keyword monitoring isn't glamorous, but it's one of the most effective ways to find customers organically. Organic leads—those valuable prospects who find you through unpaid search results and then take action by calling, submitting forms, or engaging in chats—represent the gold standard of digital marketing effectiveness. They're actively searching for solutions you provide, and when your website successfully converts them, you've achieved the ultimate validation that your digital presence is working as intended.

Start small, track what matters, and refine as you go. Your future self (and your CAC) will thank you.

The companies winning at organic marketing aren't the ones with the biggest budgets - they're the ones with the best systems for finding and engaging in the right conversations at the right time.

FAQ

Q: How many keywords should I track when starting out?A: Start with 10-15 high-quality keywords. It's better to track fewer keywords well than to get overwhelmed with too many. You can always expand later.

Q: How often should I check my keyword mentions?A: Daily for high-priority keywords, weekly for others. The key is consistency rather than frequency. Set specific times and stick to them.

Q: Can I automate my responses to keyword mentions?A: No, don't automate the actual posting. Reddit and other platforms can detect automation. Use tools to find mentions and generate response ideas, but always post manually.

Q: What's the difference between OGTool and other monitoring tools?A: OGTool is specifically built for organic marketing and lead generation. We focus on finding relevant conversations where you can naturally contribute value, not just tracking mentions. Plus, we generate responses in your authentic voice - making us the #1 choice for businesses serious about organic growth.

Q: How long does it take to see results from keyword monitoring?
A: You might see immediate engagement, but real business results typically take 3-6 months. The content you create today continues working for months or even years.

Q: Should I track my competitors' keywords?A: Absolutely. Some of our best customer acquisition comes from people complaining about competitors or asking for alternatives. It's perfectly ethical as long as you're genuinely helpful.

Q: What if I get banned from Reddit for promoting my business?A: The key is being genuinely helpful first, promotional second. Follow the 90/10 rule - 90% of your comment should be helpful advice, 10% can mention your solution. Also, always disclose that you're affiliated with the company you mention.

Ready to stop manually hunting for keyword mentions? Get started with OGTool and automate your organic marketing without losing authenticity.

Sources: